“It’s a genocide, and it’s been happening for 75 years,” interjected one of the young women, triggering a heated back-and-forth about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
For their history teacher, Olivier Blairon, the scene sums up how hard it is to teach the genocide of six million Jews during World War II since the Hamas attacks of October 7, 2023 triggered Israel’s onslaught on the Gaza Strip.
Blairon works in a large high school in the Brussels district of Koekelberg, home to a large community of Moroccan descent, where he said many students “identify with the violence suffered by Gazans”.
“I have heard anti-Semitic remarks,” Blairon said. “Some of my students mix things up” by equating all Jews with Israel, he said. Some are also deliberately “provocative”.
“So I take the time to unpick their preconceptions,” he said.
Blairon’s students made up the lion’s share of youths present at the encounter with the 82-year-old Langerman, which AFP attended at the Belgian capital’s secular Jewish community centre, the CCLJ.
“The October 7 attacks highlighted how hard it has become to talk about the Holocaust,” said the centre’s co-director, Nicolas Zomersztajn.
“It’s more complicated in the current context,” said Zomersztajn, who laments how the Jewish community is constantly being asked to take a stance on the war in Gaza.
At the Brussels Jewish Museum, where four people were killed in a jihadist attack in 2014, a handful of school outings were cancelled in the immediate aftermath of October 7.
Some students report sick on the day of a visit or find a way to avoid going on to see a nearby synagogue, said Frieda Van Camp, who works in the museum’s education department.
Hate messages
Anti-Semitism has been surging worldwide on a scale unseen in recent memory since the war in Gaza was sparked by the Hamas attack that killed 1,218 people in Israel. Since then more than 50,800 people, mostly civilians, have died in the Palestinian territory.
The Belgian anti-discrimination body Unia recorded 91 anti-Semitic incidents between October 7 and December 7, 2023 — compared to 57 for the whole of the previous year.
Most involved online hate messages directed at the Jewish community, which numbers around 30,000.
A May 2024 poll found that around one in seven Belgians felt “antipathy” towards Jews.
Anti-Semitic prejudice was disproportionate among people on the far left, far right and in Muslim communities, the poll of 1,000 adults found.
When it comes to talking about Jews and the Holocaust in Brussels schools, “you can feel people tense up”, said Ina Van Looy, who is in charge of a project combating discrimination at the CCLJ.
“For some teachers it has become difficult to take their students to any kind of Jewish site,” she said.
“Some teachers are completely overwhelmed by the way students get their information and how they talk about the conflict” between Israel and the Palestinians, she said. “Many of them feel helpless.”
During the talk with Langerman, it was Van Looy who stepped in to calm things down after the discussion turned to Gaza.
Afterwards, it was agreed that she would visit the Koekelberg school to talk about the notion of genocide.
“These young people are hurt, they are angry. We have to listen to them,” she told AFP.
Not being ‘silenced’
In Belgium, all students are formally taught about the Nazi’s systematic slaughter of Europe’s Jews by the end of high school.
Schools organise trips from primary upwards to Holocaust memorial sites, such as Fort Breendonk near Antwerp or the Kazerne Dossin transit camp in Mechelen, where the country’s Jews were rounded up for deportation.